Well, there were many comments on the technical aspects of the picture - true, it was not meant to meet "gallery standards", whatever they are, it was my idea to raise the issue.
Thanks Esti to bring the picture up, thanks the Roberts for the emotional support, thanks Patrick for the wise judgement.
I thought it was worthwile bringing it to attention to so many people. Thanks for joining the discussion and for taking your time.
Falko
This is a very delicate comment on the ravages of war. Esti could have chosen a bloody street scene or destroyed buildings which would have "spoken for itself". True gallery work would be somewhere between this image and the real horrors of battle. Sorry Esti - contra.
that is an image wich have opened an interesting discusion.....
personaly i agree with falco and robert in the point about the impact buuut i also have to agree about the quality....
also the point of view from hewig is well, too .....it could be done by an insect too.....
anyhow a documantry image with a story, but the quality could be better
my idea is.. to see the same image in bw...would be better imho...but thats just my taste ;-))
Patrick B. Parenteau 20/09/2006 8:43
I recommend that people look at the rest of this series in Esti's portfolio.Seagaul 20/09/2006 0:08
Well, there were many comments on the technical aspects of the picture - true, it was not meant to meet "gallery standards", whatever they are, it was my idea to raise the issue.Thanks Esti to bring the picture up, thanks the Roberts for the emotional support, thanks Patrick for the wise judgement.
I thought it was worthwile bringing it to attention to so many people. Thanks for joining the discussion and for taking your time.
Falko
Valfoto 19/09/2006 23:26 Commento di voto
-Patrick B. Parenteau 19/09/2006 23:26 Commento di voto
This is a very delicate comment on the ravages of war. Esti could have chosen a bloody street scene or destroyed buildings which would have "spoken for itself". True gallery work would be somewhere between this image and the real horrors of battle. Sorry Esti - contra.Christian Knospe 19/09/2006 23:26 Commento di voto
-Jaime Crystal Attenborough 19/09/2006 23:26 Commento di voto
its a lovely photo but not for gallery sorryJ
Maguire 19/09/2006 23:26 Commento di voto
more contraSeagaul 19/09/2006 23:26 Commento di voto
@celal, that is a point worth discussing, thank you !°°° celle °°° 19/09/2006 23:26 Commento di voto
that is an image wich have opened an interesting discusion.....personaly i agree with falco and robert in the point about the impact buuut i also have to agree about the quality....
also the point of view from hewig is well, too .....it could be done by an insect too.....
anyhow a documantry image with a story, but the quality could be better
my idea is.. to see the same image in bw...would be better imho...but thats just my taste ;-))
skip
Costantinos Milonas 19/09/2006 23:26 Commento di voto
Sorry contra.Mircea Tiron-Tudor 19/09/2006 23:26 Commento di voto
Not for gallery !r o l f WENGENroth 19/09/2006 23:26 Commento di voto
_Abdul Khaliq 19/09/2006 23:26 Commento di voto
-Claude Coeudevez 19/09/2006 23:26 Commento di voto
Not for galleryDominique Duriot 19/09/2006 23:26 Commento di voto
Difficult....I would say Pro for the storybut for gallery it means an excellent picture
I'll skip