Nice sculpture and a good picture, only the reflection of light on the right is a bit disturbing. I think that, even though it is a nice picture, it not that special that it should be in the gallery, sorry contra
The sculpture is VERY good...reminds me of Munch's 'The cry'... and seeing it as a threedimensional piece I'd admire it but as a photo the impact is not there for me...
Sorry, I'll skip
I went back and read the rules for the Gallery...actually rule--there was only one. It said "Exeptinal [sic] photos - voted by our users." Of course, "exceptional" is a matter of personal taste, and that's why we are given three choices. Without getting too technical, my criteria are 1) I really like it -- PRO, 2) I like it but cannot decide OR this is something I'm not into and will let others decide -- SKIP, and 3) I don't like it - CONTRA. The great thing about FC is that we're allowed to make our own rules about voting for Gallery proposals. We don't even have to comment on our choice (although I think it's impolite not to do so, especially if it's CONTRA). This particular one I really like on three fronts: the sculpture, the foto, and the story. However, I'm only allowed to give it one PRO, so I'll give it for the foto.
ok, i skip bc this is a photo that records a work of art in another medium and although very technically sound and well lit, mark's comment states my thoughts very thoroughly and eloquently.
Massimo Carolla 05/04/2007 21:07 Commento di voto
proAlexandra Baltog 05/04/2007 21:07 Commento di voto
PRO ! Excellent presentation & details...even this pic is only a sculpture...Anna Attlid 05/04/2007 21:07 Commento di voto
contra sorrydoesn't work for me
Peter. Gau 05/04/2007 21:07 Commento di voto
skipDominique Duriot 05/04/2007 21:07 Commento di voto
well for me it's Pro**Frank Cecconi 05/04/2007 21:07 Commento di voto
+Cees Kuijs 05/04/2007 21:07 Commento di voto
I give it a pro for the sculpture and for the picture.Excellent details in this golden one.Theo Weijmer 05/04/2007 21:07 Commento di voto
Nice sculpture and a good picture, only the reflection of light on the right is a bit disturbing. I think that, even though it is a nice picture, it not that special that it should be in the gallery, sorry contraClaire L. 05/04/2007 21:07 Commento di voto
The sculpture is VERY good...reminds me of Munch's 'The cry'... and seeing it as a threedimensional piece I'd admire it but as a photo the impact is not there for me...Sorry, I'll skip
Aniko Mocher 05/04/2007 21:07 Commento di voto
not gallery material...contra~Merlin~ 05/04/2007 21:07 Commento di voto
+Tom McAlexander 05/04/2007 21:07 Commento di voto
I went back and read the rules for the Gallery...actually rule--there was only one. It said "Exeptinal [sic] photos - voted by our users." Of course, "exceptional" is a matter of personal taste, and that's why we are given three choices. Without getting too technical, my criteria are 1) I really like it -- PRO, 2) I like it but cannot decide OR this is something I'm not into and will let others decide -- SKIP, and 3) I don't like it - CONTRA. The great thing about FC is that we're allowed to make our own rules about voting for Gallery proposals. We don't even have to comment on our choice (although I think it's impolite not to do so, especially if it's CONTRA). This particular one I really like on three fronts: the sculpture, the foto, and the story. However, I'm only allowed to give it one PRO, so I'll give it for the foto.Daren Borzynski 05/04/2007 21:07 Commento di voto
An excellent sculpture!!.. must be a creative family Robert.But I think I have to agree with Mark,Sarah & Dave.
Skip.
Dave Donaldson 05/04/2007 21:07 Commento di voto
Pro for the sculpture like it very nice, but contra on the shot more a docu piece , think Mark has hit the nail on the head with this one sorry ;)Sarah D. Kiefer 05/04/2007 21:07 Commento di voto
ok, i skip bc this is a photo that records a work of art in another medium and although very technically sound and well lit, mark's comment states my thoughts very thoroughly and eloquently.