Ritorna alla lista

Elena

3.566 19

Kieran Tobin

Free Account, Cork

Segui

Commenti 19

Jeremy B 18/04/2006 3:34 Commento di voto
Thanks for the explenation, and I'll change my skip to a PRO. Creative and impressive.
Jeremy B 18/04/2006 3:34 Commento di voto
I can appreciate the image as artwork, and would vote pro on that basis. However, I would like to know what this is. - If you can share w/o giving away your new trade secret. :-)
Is this actual film or slide that you've manipulated, or is this P.S. work on a photograph or scan.

Skip for now, but with the understanding that it is an impressive piece.
Patrick B. Parenteau 18/04/2006 3:34 Commento di voto
Contra - I've come back to this shot many times before making a decision. As a traditionalist, with no experience with this genre of photography, I am trying to be open minded and just let the art speak for itself. I like the colour, framing and composition but its that one stroke across the nose that kills it for me. My eye goes straight to it every time. If the intent was to make the viewer uncomfortable or anxious as Wen says, it worked, but not in a way I can appreciate. Sorry. If I percieved a flaw or didn't like the emotion from a traditional photograph, I would vote the same way.
Cees Kuijs 18/04/2006 3:34 Commento di voto
Contra
Valfoto 18/04/2006 3:34 Commento di voto
Sorry, contra
Robert Riley 18/04/2006 3:34 Commento di voto
I am not convinced on this one, Sorry Contra.
Abdul Khaliq 18/04/2006 3:34 Commento di voto
I am with Robert, sorry contra !
°°° celle °°° 18/04/2006 3:34 Commento di voto
abstract pro
When 18/04/2006 3:34 Commento di voto
Magnificent. I wish we drew more artists working in this art form of photography on FC. It's usually not very appreciated here, in a forum that holds traditional photography values very high, but I hope enough people appreciate what you are doing Kieran. There is an uncomfortableness to the picture, it almost gives the viewer an anxious feeling. I'm dying to see your exhibition. Going to be in the US any time soon?
Claire L. 18/04/2006 3:34 Commento di voto
Absolutely pro !
Jan Van Der Hooft 18/04/2006 3:34 Commento di voto
Contra
Roberto Grilli 18/04/2006 3:34 Commento di voto
This is not a "classic" photography picture.
I like the technique. I don't like the line over the nose.
The eyes are saying something bad and don't corespond with the lips.
These are my feelings of the pic.
I will come back.
Skip+ at the moment.
Robert Riley 18/04/2006 3:34 Commento di voto
I really don't know what to make of this. As art it has its place, as Photography, I am not sure. There does not appear to be too much of a Photograph here, which has to be a starting point, on FC. Just a comment for now, but inclined to Contra.
Dennis Veldman 18/04/2006 3:34 Commento di voto
intense.
PRO
Kieran Tobin 18/04/2006 3:34 Commento di voto
I just had my first exhibition in the Tigh Fili gallery in Cork City, Ireland. As far as I knnow I come up with a new way of printing an such images.. If you do know of any one else doing the same work I'ld be happy to hear from them. Kieran