let's rule the world Foto % Immagini| still life, subjects Foto su fotocommunity

Sarah D. Kiefer 19/04/2007 5:55 Commento di voto

thanks to all who commented and voted... good to see discussion as always!

Jacqueline Chay 19/04/2007 5:55 Commento di voto

Could not work out if it was Pro or Anti smoking. - Contra - Nice idea though

Abdul Khaliq 19/04/2007 5:55 Commento di voto

Same as Ruud.
-

Roberto Grilli 19/04/2007 5:55 Commento di voto

The idea is very good. The message is clear (to me anyway). The final picture is not strong enough for that message.
sorry
contra

Oliver Suhr 19/04/2007 5:55 Commento di voto

I don't like the text, but it is still pro.

Peter. Gau 19/04/2007 5:55 Commento di voto

Have seen better shots of this type here, the cigarette in front is burned out at the top and that bothers me. Also find the crop on the left not so good.
A good picture but not outstanding imo. Sorry, -

MWPhoto 19/04/2007 5:55 Commento di voto

photo is so-so
but
photo + text = potent image
and I am an image guy ...
this image succeeds for me, thanks Sarah!

When 19/04/2007 5:55 Commento di voto

Good one Sarah. Thanks for bringing Jitaru's images to my attention. Fantastic creative and thoughtful series.

Robert Riley 19/04/2007 5:55 Commento di voto

I think I see the point, that is, Tobacco Barons exploitation of the third world. But maybe wrong. Judging the photo, its not good enough for the Gallery.

I dont like the crop, the lead fag is badly positioned, and it is blown out at the top. Could have been a great deal better.

Véronique Soulier 19/04/2007 5:55 Commento di voto

all is said, no for me too, sorry

DRAGA PUC 19/04/2007 5:55 Commento di voto

there is no other option
p r o

Alexandra Baltog 19/04/2007 5:55 Commento di voto

PRO...and a BIG...booster! ;-)

Susie Q 19/04/2007 5:55 Commento di voto

Not gallery for me sorry ...

Dominique Duriot 19/04/2007 5:55 Commento di voto

sorry dont see it...

Stefan S. Mosley 19/04/2007 5:55 Commento di voto

Where's the "WOW" effect you always yearn for, Sarah? I join the others here and wonder if you see values that none of us do here.
Contra

Sezione	Subjects: Still life
Visto da	2.696
Pubblicato	07/04/2007
Lingua
Licenza

let's rule the world

jitaru claudiu