Ritorna alla lista
Up

Up

3.001 18
0
Robert van der Sanden

Robert van der Sanden


Free Account, Hooge Mierde

Up

Oak Mountain State Park, Alabama

Canon F1n, 200mm, Kodak Portra 160NC

On my road towards fine art photography, I wonder what feeling this picture gives to the viewer. Is this something you would hang on your wall? Any thoughts about that are appreciated.

Commenti 18

  • Maria Kyselicova

    Maria Kyselicova 19/09/2006 18:43

    so einfach, so farbig, so ruhig...
    maria
    Metti mi piace
  • Robert van der Sanden

    Robert van der Sanden 19/05/2006 19:35

    @Detlef: thanks for sharing your thought. I will play with your idea and see how that works out.
    Robert
    Metti mi piace
  • Detlef Klahm

    Detlef Klahm 19/05/2006 14:19

    This is an interesting image...full of new life...unspoiled by mans hand.
    one of the things I find very distracting here is the bright background. though the main trunk is interesting but does not really hold you there. the eye wanders around.
    what if you would have closed in on the new growth and the trunk as a macro shot?
    just another opinion, another thought. Keep up the good work !
    Metti mi piace
  • Robert van der Sanden

    Robert van der Sanden 27/04/2006 17:33

    OK, I'll get in touch with you outside fc.
    Metti mi piace
  • Laki K.

    Laki K. 26/04/2006 20:29

    hi robert, that would be nice to get a copy of it ;-) but to make things easier it would be enough to email me a bigger file so i would print it out here, just if you dont mind ;-)

    cheers
    laki
    Metti mi piace
  • Robert van der Sanden

    Robert van der Sanden 25/04/2006 20:56

    Thanks Laki! I can always send you a copy :-)
    greetings,
    Robert
    Metti mi piace
  • Laki K.

    Laki K. 25/04/2006 20:29

    definately a photo which i would hang on my wall, on the opposite wall of my desk. very nice colors, good crop and the bokeh is very nice.

    cheers
    laki
    Metti mi piace
  • Robert van der Sanden

    Robert van der Sanden 20/04/2006 20:33

    Thanks Mark, that's a very positive and assuring message.

    Reading all your remarks I feel I best follow the path and have faith in the outcome. I guess artistic skills will need time to mature, like a good wine.
    ...mmm, a dark beer will do...
    Metti mi piace
  • MWPhoto

    MWPhoto 20/04/2006 20:07

    Robert, I just want to comment on the "would you hang it on the wall" test, because that was my first impulse when I saw this picture: I can easily envision it on my wall at work (a modern professional office, where serenity is valued) but not at home (a hobbit's hole of antiques!). So the "wall" test depends on which wall!
    I think it is a very fine photo. I would have a nice Burgundy with it. Cheers.
    Metti mi piace
  • Robert van der Sanden

    Robert van der Sanden 20/04/2006 19:32

    Thank you all for your constructive comments!
    @Ruud: sure, some people like a heavy Bordeaux wine, others prefer a lighter South African wine. But all want a good wine. I like to reach an artistic quality in fine art photography that will make people (who like the subject) want to hang the picture on their wall. My last four uploads should be an example of the sort of work I have in mind, where this particular picture is not the best one.
    On the path towards that goal I sometimes feel pretty uncertain what it takes to really move people with the pictures I take. I guess that process takes time.
    I really appreciate the support you all gave me so far.
    Warm wishes,
    Robert
    Metti mi piace
  • Anastasiya Ivanova

    Anastasiya Ivanova 20/04/2006 15:25

    I think those dark parts in the background which are not in good harmony with the closest trunk especially in color performance, and yes they are a little of distraction. The view however looks pretty good and pleases me.
    Anastasia
    Metti mi piace
  • Robert van der Sanden

    Robert van der Sanden 20/04/2006 8:19

    Good point, at first I thought the trunk at the left was needed to create some balance in the shot but I will play with a different crop.
    Question: even with that point fixed, would anyone hang this on their wall and enjoy it? Honest answer (no hard feelings...)?
    Robert
    Metti mi piace
  • Robert van der Sanden

    Robert van der Sanden 19/04/2006 22:23

    Thanks Debbie for your thoughts. I get what you mean and I will give your idea of darkening a try.
    Robert
    Metti mi piace
  • Robert van der Sanden

    Robert van der Sanden 11/04/2006 20:11

    thanks :-)
    Metti mi piace
  • Cees Kuijs

    Cees Kuijs 29/03/2006 19:57

    Good position of the tree. The background is well blurred.
    Greetings, Cees
    Metti mi piace
Proposta galleria

Tag

critique - straight and tough subjects

Altre foto di Robert van der Sanden

Informazioni

Sezione Subjects: Critique - straight and tough
Visto da 3.001
Pubblicato
Lingua
Licenza